Ok, keep in mind graal kingdoms is entirely based off the open source mmo project "crossfire" all the alchemical recipes are the same, if you want to know every recipe, it's not hard, go to the crossfire sourceforge and download the alchemy file. Just keep in mind alchemy is used to make potions, waters, etc. It was never meant to make weapons and armor and other items, cloaks etc are tannery and a tanner's bench for the "cauldron" item. Which is why most of the said recipes don't work in graal kingdoms, except for a few which have been modified to work in a cauldron, I doubt they cared enough to rewrite all the recipes to work in a cauldron. If you ask me, I think the only reason graal kingdoms exists is to occupy stupid people and keep people interested in graal and to fund graal 3D until it is released and can compete with real MMORPGs.
I'd say Cyberjoueurs is a pathetic, immature little setup. Personally, I was interested in purchasing a licsence to the graal engine, but their website is hardly functional enough to do so. Take a look for yourself.
http://www.cyberjoueurs.com/