rate please

[Cid_Night]

sorry about the rate thing but i just gave this a little time and i wanted to see what some other level makers thought of it. The crew at DD liked it alot...its my first time really using edge tiles alot, and i tried to perfect them. Gimme some pointers please on how to make it better...some of you might have seen this level, its been in a couple other threads already...thanks = )

[MysticZhadow]

Kojiro: I would rate this level 4/10 because you need more detail add different tiles on the paths and the water edges are to straight need to more wavey, and in my opnion I think half
grass tiles are Ugly!!

[Cid_Night]

edge tiles too straight?? they dont go more then 2 tiles without turning lol
-edit- and wait?! there are no paths, how can i add detail? are you talking about the right level?

[Waltz5]

If you knew how to actually tile good, then you'd know what he's talking about.

It's not that bad though, I mean the cliff tiles, from grass to water and the only things that I'd make more wavey.. as he said. And yes, half grass tiles are very ugly.
And there is no like, set path... I'd like to see atleast a little dirt place where people would be constantly walking. And the dirt, there are more tiles to use inside it.

[Cid_Night]

Originally posted by Waltz5
If you knew how to actually tile good, then you'd know what he's talking about.

im not really sure why that was necessary, becuz i knew what he was talking about and there really isnt a path...you say there is then u contradict yourself by saying you'd like to see one...but whatever, ya i could add some more tiles to the dirt and maybe take out some of the swamp tiles that are in the grass, i suppose thats what you mean are ugly...thats an old DD trick that you'll see throughout the server as a way to make the grass more interesting...

[Saithe Kikou]

blah, you forced me ;/ ,anyways like i said the water and dirt edges are to straight, add some detail to the water some.Other then thats its pretty good. 6/10