Quote:
Originally Posted by papajchris
What i was getting at was the fact he didn't offer an insight on how to make it look better, nor as he attempted to make it look better (as Rogue did in his picture above.) Anyone who has passed the 11th grade knows that you can't make an effective persuasive/argument essay without providing a resolution to the problem or a theory. I was always taught that if you have an issue with something, go ahead and change it. And that carries over on too here. If anyone has an issue with the unstick me location, create a better one or propose ideas. You cant just say "THIS SUCKS"
|
The problem with your theory is that the OP didn't say "THIS SUCKS" nor was he attempting to provide a critical analysis of the unstick me area. The entire point of his thread was to point out a LACK of updates/work, as he stated earlier himself.
Other people then began to critique, which is fine. Obviously there is a distinct difference between constructive criticism and useless complaining.
Your response
Quote:
|
I can't seem to find the work YOU did?
|
seemed to go one of two directions:
You realized that he was complaining about a lack of work/updates, and insinuated that he's part of the problem.. If this is the case, your argument is completely illogical. Obviously he's not staff, so obviously even if he had work/updates in mind or prepared the chances of them being implemented are incredibly slim.
OR
You thought he was critiquing the "update" he was pointing out, thereby giving the impression that one needs to have work prepared in order to critique a work. You did not say "Where's the work OR well-constructed critique YOU'VE prepared?" You just asked for work.
All that to say, it seems your first post must have been plagued by a lack of reading comprehension and good wording, because I agree with everything you said in your second post.