Planet

[Stephen]

Originally Posted by Tyrial

It sucks enough for me to say it sucks.

Look who has the bad attitude now? He suggests you're a scammer and suddenly his work sucks, when it really doesn't. That's pretty childish, man.

[Lord Sephiroth]

Sometimes when I look at it I like it for it's uniqueness and other times when I look at it I just see it as a poor copy.

[Zideruic]

I've got 10$ on Elk not taking any of our advise and just using the ****ty rough draft he posted.

[SayianOozaru]

damn, very nice elk

Originally Posted by Stephen

Look who has the bad attitude now? He suggests you're a scammer and suddenly his work sucks, when it really doesn't. That's pretty childish, man.

these kids are always on the forums...they really do get annouying after awhile...after reading 3 pages of "you suck" it gets kinda old...not sure why they do it either...i gotta better things to waste my time with then ***** at someone over the internet lol, but i guess they dont o.o

[Stephen]

Originally Posted by Zideruic

I've got 10$ on Elk not taking any of our advise and just using the ****ty rough draft he posted.

Probably, that's not a surprise. But what difference does it make? It's his choice.

[Zideruic]

Why even post it if he's going to bark at us for telling him that he needs to improve on some small things in order for it to be good quality?

[Mykel]

Africa sucks

Other than that, it's a million times better than anything I'll ever do, so:

10/10

[lancelot9]

i dont even care... i like it, its good work
even if it is supposed to be earth.. i can see it being earth.. but i also cant see it being earth... no ice caps.. no deserts etc

nice work, its a planet thats all that matters to me

[Em]

Originally Posted by konidias

The image would look loads better if you did a better job with the dithering of the shading with the water. A sphere would not create that effect. Regardless of what the surface was like. Because it's from such a distance that you'd only see it as a perfect sphere.

My thoughts exactly; still, it's pretty cool.

[Elk]

Originally Posted by Demisis_P2P

Meh, it's not all that good.
I don't think planets shine like that.
And it does need some AA.
It also lacks any kind of atmosphere and the way the continents are shaded is weird. You're already using quite a lot of colours, so you may as well have gone a little bit further and used a few more to make the continents look better.

It does NOT need AA
and quite alot of colors were needed to make it like that.
Dithering isnt needed in this piece aswell

[Demisis_P2P]

Originally Posted by Elk

It does NOT need AA
and quite alot of colors were needed to make it like that.
Dithering isnt needed in this piece aswell

Yeah I knew, 20 colours. So why not go the extra mile and make it 24 colours and improve the quality of the continents?

Your lighting is still wrong though, as Stephen and I both pointed out.

[Elk]

It's MY planet
so it's right

[Crono]

it looks better without AA, the jaggedyness of the corners kind of fit with the apparent bumpyness of the planet.

[Elk]

riiiight

[Demisis_P2P]

Elk doesn't know what you're talking about because the planet isn't bumpy, that's just his lame way of shading the continents. The fact that it looks bumpy is why I told him he should fix them.