What do you think of the current Classic worlds?
 

I was just wondering what people thought about the current servers that we have on the Classic tab, are some of them a waste of resources? Should they all undergo PWA inspections to see if they fit the category still? What would you change about them?

We currently have, in alphabetical order:
Atlantis
Classic
Delteria
Era
Maloria
N-Pulse
Unholy Nation
Valikorlia
Zodiac

Constructive comments only please.

I don't really play much anymore, but they should all have regular inspections by the pwa, and if they don't fit the requirements to be left on classic, then they should be removed.
I also think that punishments for breaking the rules should be dealt with stricter.

Before we can talk inspections, we need to talk fully established pwa team that can handle that kind of job and do that kind of work with proper leadership and help.

Before we can talk about that we have to be able to discuss flaws in that staff team, besides you said "Constructive only".

You are jumping the gun a little imo, besides, taking servers off the classic list does nothing for the game at all besides make it look even more barren and desolate then it already does, and giving the players a very limited choice of places to go.

Work from bottom -> up

Maloria is dead, but thats because all the staff are working on v3 since v2 is ancient and god - it still use gs1.

In my opinion, the content of the current servers needs to be tweaked before any form of advertising is made, which seems to be what everyone believes Graal needs.

The Classic list currently..

http://img242.imageshack.us/img242/5648/classic1ls5.gif

To me, having servers with 0 players online makes the place more empty, rather then say..

http://img378.imageshack.us/img378/8886/classic2ma0.gif

Atlantis - Everything is in GERMAN...I dont play there but they have a lovely overworld.

Classic - Havent really payed there that much...its a classic graal server, not much more to say.

Delteria - Was fun for awhile when I first started. Classes are kind of unbalanced. Gets kinda old just PK'ing alot and having a limited ammount of quests.

Era - Shooting guns is fun for awhile.. Picking flowers endlessy when you first start out is all right. Fun to explore though.

Maloria - Kinda died (contrary to GAMBET's opinion, it was not because he left), I work there so I cant really give an unbiased opinion. But I think everyone had fun for awhile, the endless grinding with not much else to do but PK, join a nation, explore, and do a few quests probably pushed everyone away. Not to mention the corruption and the duping glitches that everyone under the sun abused and drove our economy into RUIN. Look out for v3! It shall be awesome (for our sakes I hope it is).

N-Pulse - Havent really had much time on this server. It's all right.

Unholy Nation - Got just about everything in a couple of days...didnt really want to PK the entire time I was there after I went through all the quests so...I moved on. Some really screwed up people on this server.

Valikorlia - I love the mini overworld and some of the graphics are nice. But besides RP'ing there reallly isnt anything to do.

Zodiac - Not quite endless grinding...but leveling, protecting a fort, capturing a town, and killing other people is basically all you can do. Graphics suck something awful and some of the particle effects could look a WHOLE lot better.

As James said the problem with that is having a fully established, well running PWA Team which graal currently lacks.

Also, If that were the case we'd be removing current servers and we'd have like 2 or 3 on the classic list (That may not be a problem for some people), because the current expectations of UC servers are way too high, we'd never see a new server.

We're lucky we got Zodiac with their laggy scripts.

You have to understand that Graal's servers host up to 30 playerworlds on the same machine.
Zodiac requires a lot of server <-> client communication, to keep things such as HP, MP, ect. updated.
Also, we use a lot of spell effects and the such. It's not mean't for old computers; if you experience slow down while playing, your computer is too old. In my experience, most of Graal has out of date/crappy computers.

just get to the point yen your trying to ask what they think of zodiac

No he wasnt?

I think some servers shud have a certain player min avg. to be on classic

Atlantis: It's German. I know very little about it, but it should be kept for that reason alone.

Classic: It has a consistant and loyal playerbase. I haven't played the server much, but I know that people who do care about it a lot and are very dedicated.

Delteria: It should be removed. People don't play it, and Delteria is currently under heavy construction with their new server. I see no reason for it to be on the classic list.

Era: To-date still the most successful modern server, although it has dropped in playerbase a bit with the addition of Zodiac. Nice alternative for the players to turn to, if they like that kind of thing.

Maloria: Talk about dying quick. I don't really know what to say. It wont compete unless it makes it's roleplaying better than Val or level-up system better than Zodiac's. Good luck.

N-Pulse: The typical "classic" server. It still gets a consistant playerbase and seems to be live and active.

Unholy Nation: The huge community only helps make itself larger. A nice events system and active guilds help keep this server bangin'.

Valikorlia: Role playing. That about sums it up.

Zodiac: It utilizes the player's desire to become powerful better than any other classic playerworld, and that is why it is so successful.

Maloria has only fallen because of Zodiac..and Zodiac is just somthing new for the people who played Maloria. Im sure the next server that has the level up theme will take Zodiacs place.

Delteria is just there no clue why its on the list

Classic....dont know to much about it

Val...should be taken down

Pulse.... dieing cause theyve been working on some sort "good"(lol) update for who knows how long

UN...Same crap as usual...seems like a good place to spar these days though

Era.....Living Large still..kinda

Atlantis.....ahh I speak German so I dont rlly know..but I never see anyone there anymore no matter what time.

graal Classic servers in general are pretty lame if you ask me.

Grades are rated on importance/keepability:
1-Should be removed
5-Needs to be kept

Atlantis: I see very little people on it at any time, and i'm a Night Owl. In fact, I can't remember the last time I saw -anyone- on it. - 2

Classic: The playerbase is loyal, as Mykel said, but the playerbase is too small and the level quality, although classic and old school, isn't adaptive to todays average Graal Player. - 3

Delteria: Needs to be taken off the Classic list untill new Updates are completed. Maybe given the same options that Babylon has? Either way, it shouldn't be on the classic list in the state that it's in. - 1

Era: Still Active, still going strong, so to speak. Appeals to the player that feels like escaping real life into...uh...a real life simulator--with more guns. - 5

Maloria: Maloria has been knocked off it's high-horse by Zodiac hard. From this standpoint Maloria really needs to make some Staff-Changes and get things moving if they ever want to take back their server terrotory from Zodiac, but by the amounts of Updates Yen seems to spend his life doing, that doesn't look like it's going to happen. - 1

N-Pulse: N-Pulse needs a lot of work, as well as Management and Administration Changes. The N-Pulse community has a terrible staff team that never seems to get things done. They've been working on these new OW updates for how long now? People are tired of waiting, and at this point they'd be lucky if they get anyone to even notice Overworld changes when they do it.
Events are poor quality, everything is generally poor quality. - 3

Unholy Nation: Active Guilds Community, Active Playerbase, still the top server of the age, even if no-one really knows why. Very attractive to the newer players, a vital part (as sad as it is) of the current Graal Generation. 5

Valikorlia: Although Clash sucks something fierce, (I'm not sure if he even works there anymore, I just hate clash because he's a terrible Manager of anything), the newer Val, although not measuring up to the old school Val that we all knew and loved, still maintains a high 60+ Player count per day, and appeals largely to the Role-Play playerbase, even if the levels suck ass and the Role-Play system could be made better and glitches fixed. - 4

Zodiac: Yen successfully kills his social life by spending all his time updating Zodiac, there's no telling how long that's going to last, a lot of things could be improved, and I mean a lot of things.
A LOT of things, but Zodiac is appealing to Malorias crowd as well as newer players, as much as I hate to say it, vital to the community as of right now. 5

We don't necessarily need a large amount of servers as much as a few servers with high playercounts and good quality. Many online games have only a few servers but very high playercounts, and this provides for much more player interaction (which is what makes Graal what it is). All of the most successful servers (such as UN, Era, and Zodiac) have extremely high playercounts, which make things like guilds, nations, PKing, party systems, and businesses fun.

When you go to a server with a much smaller playercount such as NPulse or Maloria, it is a much more tightknit group of players who all know each other and it can be somewhat intimidating for a new player.

While it is a tricky subject because it is only fair to give every player a shot at running their own online world, I think the server list and Graal in general could do with a little shake-up.

Gold and Classic playerworlds should only be those few servers which are fully up and running with plenty of content and an active staff team, and should all be closely watched and overseen by the Graal staff themselves. Because Gold and Classic playerworlds are the ones seen and played on by the majority of players, especially new ones, it only makes sense to make sure they are of the highest quality.

The Hosted tab should be used almost like the classic tab is now, for the newer playerworlds run entirely by players that have a decent amount of content but are not quite finished yet. These playerworlds can still be seen on the main list, which makes them easily accessed, but are generally not a part of the first impression a new Graal players gets.

The website should also provide more information to players about Hosted playerworlds and playerworlds that are Under Construction so that they know what is out there and what they can try. As of right now the only way I know of for a player to find out about an Under Construction server is to hear about it on the forums or to see it on the RC list (which many new players won't have a clue how to do) and type it into the box.

In conclusion, and for those who didn't feel like reading everything, I think a server-list with a few high-quality Gold and Classic servers with large playercounts, and then a Hosted tab for those servers who are completely re-doing everything (like Delteria, Maloria, and N-Pulse) would look much more attractive to new players and would help deal with the "empty" feeling that the serverlist has now. Seeing a few servers with playercounts of 100+ looks better than seven or eight with 60 or 70, or as little as 10 or even 0.