I want to see the classic storyline with main quests, sidequests, and social interaction (hang out spots, events, sparring). I want to be able to log on to Classic and choose whether I want to do quests and get max sword level, max shield level, max hearts, etc. or just hang out and interact with other Graalians. I would also like to see "non-classic" features such as hats.
I would say a mix between the era when Thym's Quest was first released, and the era when the Hera's were released. Something close to that.