[Minomato]

I want to state that I still don't like the "holly leaf sabre," that IXI made. The shading is a bit strange, and it doesn't look too much like a leaf. (Not to mention, it does look like a wierd tree with the star on the tip.)

The star saw has the appearance of a vaccuum of sorts, the sawblade itself isn't even or symmetrical, and the up/down views show that the handle and motor aren't connected to the saw end. Scale needs to be fixed to fit with the player size, and the hinge where the star blade is connected to the main body of the weapon via the red speckled green pole extending from the 'vaccuum' like feature is off center of the star.

Unless these are rough weapon ideas, I wouldn't say these are ready for game use. I'd say go for the holly sabre, it'd be cleaner, more simplistic, and it only needs a few more changes. Make some more weapon directions for the sabre, so it can be used in ganis and whatnot.

As for Liberated's weapons, the pepperment (white/red striped) theme came out pretty well, although I'd have to say that the first weapon looks like it's draped in a tangled scarf, and.. I dare say.. It kind of resembles the Ghost Rifle when I compare the graphics. But anyway, the second gun looks pretty neat. The projectile you provided with that one can be a "charge" shot for it, while the ranged shot from the Candy Reapers can be salvaged for it's normal attack. Peppermint Rifle, eh? Although, I don't know if people want any MORE plasma-type rifles.