Silence's theme. (Poll)

[Soala]

First, HI !

So, I just made this thread to know what kind of server you people would like to play.
Actually, I'm stuck with 2 ideas, and such the 2nd idea came from Jamie, but still I really don't know which way to go !

Current server: RPG/Fantasy theme
-a main gmap composed of many islands
-quests
-dungeons
-lvling
-baddies and such !
-Custom HP/MP GUI !
-Jobs : Mining/Crafting, Fishing/Cooking (including potions making)
-Kingdoms/Empire systems

Jamie's idea: Pirate themed server-
Epic Boat Battles~ Sink NPC/Player ships or grapple and fight the members on board at sword combat.
Blockade island to take control and build up your flags empire.
Crew and Flag system enabling players to join together in massive battles.
Money is earnt through pillaging the seas from NPC and Player ships!
Two Gmaps, one for land and one for sea. Sail to other islands and buy/sell merchandise at ports.
Collect materials either from hunting monsters on land or by defeating enemies on sea.
No leveling system, but includes a Rank system (Ranging from Jobbing Pirate to Captain in Crews, then from Royalty to King of a flag!).
Default GUI, Q Menu and HP System, but with custom weapons, ranging from a single wooden sword, to dual cleavers and even the legendary Great Sword.

Choose, because both ideas are fine, tho RPG/Fantasy idea would be what I would choose but Graal doesn't have such a pirate themed server !