1st Official Graalian Artist's Challenge: Finals!!

[LordZen]

First of all I'd like to say that I think this turned out really well, and I appreciate everybody who participated in this event.

Alright, I picked out what I felt was the top 5 entries. I will show them in now particular order, you guys get a week to vote on this? Tell me if you think that is too long.

A:

B:

C:

D:

E:

Also tell me if you think voting is the best way to do it, and should I vote? And if so, should my vote be weighted a bit more? Say worth 5? I say this because I think some of you will be unhappy with choosing to vote since the results may not be entirely accurate.

[Crono]

I bet that if you had added mine everyone would have voted for it. :O

[Myomoto]

I know i would

[Goboom]

A week sounds good, its not too long although three days might be ideal. I think you should be able to vote Zen, but your vote can be worth say two so it wont be a blowout.

HAHA! I just noticed my monkey is the only one with transparency.

[Monkeyboy_McGee]

I voted for the monkey with a wang for a foot XD
Lol, it was a tough choice between the morbid one in A and the happy one in C, so i chose the happy one, it had more expression to it, and it looks very nice too

[Spark910]

Tough competition there, nice creations everyone who entered =)

[Myomoto]

Heh, the next time your gonna do this, make a freehand freestyle one ;P

[osrs]

I voted for Entry D. It's more detailed in my opinion and i like detailed stuff.

[Darlene159]

Originally Posted by osrs

I voted for Entry D. It's more detailed in my opinion and i like detailed stuff.

Same here..
Very good job everyone

[GoZelda]

I chose entry D; it's funny with the music box, it looks like one of those stuffed pet machine thing.

[Destorm]

Some "artist's" challenge... more like a popularity contest.

[Spark910]

Originally Posted by Destorm

Some "artist's" challenge... more like a popularity contest.

How so?
No offence to the other artists (who I don't know - as their names aren't listed) but if it was I think Scott would win because of his other artwork, but he is not currently winning... and yeah maybe next time it could be done by emailing them in to stop it but I don't think it will be based on popularity and even if it is it will be fun and everyone who entered should be happy with what they made, and future competitions can be improved.

[Butz]

::shrugs:: I don't really care who wins really. I had fun doing it, and it gave me something to do while I was bored at work. ^.^; Heck, I didn't even vote for my own. =P

[haunter]

Awww... I wanted to vote for Teshy's Oh well... *click*

[davidpsy]

Originally Posted by Spark910

How so?
No offence to the other artists (who I don't know - as their names aren't listed) but if it was I think Scott would win because of his other artwork, but he is not currently winning... and yeah maybe next time it could be done by emailing them in to stop it but I don't think it will be based on popularity and even if it is it will be fun and everyone who entered should be happy with what they made, and future competitions can be improved.

Scott is in the lead now .