Rate my tileset!

mhermher · #1 02-11-2003, 08:41 PM

Please rate my tileset i made this past 2-3 months...

Rate it from 1-10... and please post CONSTRUCTIVE comments/critizm.

Spark910 · #2 02-11-2003, 09:03 PM

Is that tree from somewhere else? Also the houses are good, but the wood brown blends together too much and looks like a big lump. Sign is cool, and I love the bird table idea! Castle walls = <3 Hmm.. The dirt path looks okay, but doesn't fit too well the way it looks. All nice

Kinatt · #3 02-11-2003, 09:18 PM

mhermher · #4 02-11-2003, 09:18 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Spark910
Is that tree from somewhere else? Also the houses are good, but the wood brown blends together too much and looks like a big lump. Sign is cool, and I love the bird table idea! Castle walls = <3 Hmm.. The dirt path looks okay, but doesn't fit too well the way it looks. All nice

No, tree stump is by me... The houses was given to me in a very very early stage... no vertical houses, just a plain horizontinal one... Yeah... everyone liked the castle walls.. the dirt isnt done, just the grass sides of it... im going to make the dirt real dirt

osrs · #5 02-12-2003, 01:11 AM

Rating:9/10

Gastly is back

By the way,nice graphics.Good Work.

Quote:

Originally posted by Kinatt
weee

Spam is not allowed.

AlexH · #6 02-12-2003, 01:27 AM

Everything looks great besides the house tiles.
Also the straight grass edges could use a little work by making a few of the grass blades longer going further into the water/dirt.
It looks too straight and square just now.

LordZen · #7 02-12-2003, 04:17 AM

Got some of that from ******************

maybe just the houses I dunno.

Also the castle stuff on bottom left looks strangely familiar, I think DarkVillin showed it to me before x.x didnt you work there for a while or something?

Sorry for those accusations but I know for fact the houses are from *** and so I just had to ask (even tho you stated the houses were)

edit:
Arg the name and even the shorthand is blocked out :grrr: well you know what game I'm talking about, the one LordHelmut made.

mhermher · #8 02-12-2003, 10:29 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by LordZen
Got some of that from ****************** maybe just the houses I dunno.

Also the castle stuff on bottom left looks strangely familiar, I think DarkVillin showed it to me before x.x didnt you work there for a while or something?

Sorry for those accusations but I know for fact the houses are from *** and so I just had to ask (even tho you stated the houses were)

edit:
Arg the name and even the shorthand is blocked out :grrr: well you know what game I'm talking about, the one LordHelmut made.

The houses is from LH's game...
But anyways, that castle wall is mine. DarkVillin stole it from me and said its his. Thats why i don't trust him anymore.
And no, i never worked for him, and never will.

azuretek23 · #9 02-12-2003, 07:46 PM

I've seen almost all those tiles before, I only know who made a few of them. But whatever, those tiles to fit together.. 3 different styles and only one style is semi good.

mhermher · #10 02-12-2003, 09:18 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by azuretek23
I've seen almost all those tiles before, I only know who made a few of them. But whatever, those tiles to fit together.. 3 different styles and only one style is semi good.

You probably mean Shrimp and SSmutz, they are the makers of the houses, all i did was made new tiles for it... but all other tiles are mine.

Edit: Where have you seen all those tiles before?
Edit2: O.o
I wonder who rated it "Very bad" I'd like to see he/she make a better one.

LordZen · #11 02-13-2003, 01:34 AM

Oh DV stole it you say? Alright well that explains why I had seen it before :o didnt mean to step on anybody's toes.

SSRobgeta · #12 02-13-2003, 01:51 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by LordZen
:o didnt mean to step on anybody's toes.

Neither do I when I dance :grins:

mhermher · #13 02-13-2003, 01:49 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by SSRobgeta

Neither do I when I dance :grins:

Neither do i when i tell you to stay on topic.

Stay on topic.

By the way Zen, it's all right... everybody makes misstakes.

MadWolf · #14 02-21-2003, 05:36 PM

The water is very intresting. The grass is a bit bland, and your houses kinda say "look at me only." =/ nice try though.

Devil · #15 03-04-2003, 03:07 PM

Hey I actually quite like this tileset, I give it a 8/10!
Good work Tyrial, atleast it's better than some tilesets -_- *MALORIA*

-Brett

mhermher · #16 03-04-2003, 03:08 PM

Hehe Thanks... when i made Malorias tileset well.. lets say "i was young"

tlf288 · #17 03-04-2003, 03:55 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by mhermher

I wonder who rated it "Very bad" I'd like to see he/she make a better one.

Wait, so to say I don't like something I have to be able to make something better? Well let me tell you something, I know what I like and don't like, and I can't neccesarily make something better than the things I don't.

mhermher · #18 03-04-2003, 04:09 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by tlf288

Wait, so to say I don't like something I have to be able to make something better? Well let me tell you something, I know what I like and don't like, and I can't neccesarily make something better than the things I don't.

No, i never said that.. but you could of readen my first post. POST COMMENTS WHY YOU RATE IT.

What i mean is, someone voted "Very bad" without telling me why and stuff.. and sure, i would want to see the person do better, but if he/she don't want to its his/her problem.

MilkyWay0016 · #19 03-07-2003, 01:19 AM

It's okay. The graphics by themselves are good but they don't really fit together. Just some suggestions:
-The path doesn't work with anything.. maybe you're still working on it, but it doesn't look changed at all
-the crates are too smushed together, and don't really have any depth
-the sign is too small in compairson to the house
-The front of the white houses look very good when compaired to the others, but the other houses are great!
-Too many cracks in the dungeon walls...
-The bottom of the tree you made looks a lot like a 2k2 tree... not that you stole it or anything, they are different, just FYI they don't completly fit with your houses, etc.

tlf288 · #20 03-07-2003, 01:57 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by mhermher

i would want to see the person do better, but if he/she don't want to its his/her problem.

Are you truly that ignorant? A person DOES NOT need to be better or even have an idea of how to do what he\she is commenting on. What they have to know is if they like it.
and
How is it his/her problem? Because that person doesn't like something it suddenly if their problem they can't or don't want to do better? I don't see your point here

mhermher · #21 03-07-2003, 03:34 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by tlf288

Are you truly that ignorant? A person DOES NOT need to be better or even have an idea of how to do what he\she is commenting on. What they have to know is if they like it.
and
How is it his/her problem? Because that person doesn't like something it suddenly if their problem they can't or don't want to do better? I don't see your point here

OKay, i'll say this fast.. my point is that i want them to say whats bad not just "rate 1, bye" atleast comment it.

Knuckles · #22 03-09-2003, 12:05 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by mhermher
Please rate my tileset i made this past 2-3 months...

Rate it from 1-10... and please post CONSTRUCTIVE comments/critizm.

I don't like how the dirt border or water border looks. But it's good. O_O. GJ.

View Poll Results: Rate it
Very Good!	6	33.33%
Good	6	33.33%
Okay	3	16.67%
Bad	1	5.56%
Very Bad!	2	11.11%
Voters: 18. You may not vote on this poll