[dorfindel]

Well, the brown sandish thing in the water isn't tiled in correctly, but I think that's because you forgot to detail the water...which I will leave alone for now. I personally think there should be a bit more deep in places though...Blah I don't like those water tiles..the other ones are better o_o...but whatever.

Also, the grass tiling is terrible. It's just plain green with tall grass. Way too booooriiing. There's a little other stuff...but barely any.

Oh yeah, 3/10.

Also, lots of tile errors in the cliffs.

And one thing that I really hate is using images for trees...just tile them damn it. maybe it doesn't look as good or whatever, but I could tell from that screen that you used treetop.gif...and that is definitely a bad thing. Trees that you can walk behind are stupid, it doesn't fit in with the rest of the way the classic worlds are setup, and you didn't even do it right.

It's not really bad though.