This isnt an official review, but it should be good enough to rate the server..
This server does that have much to do on it. You start out on a little island with no jobs, or anything except one slash100baddiesandgetafullheart quest, which I got a bow from and not a fullheart so I cant even call it that.
Creativity - 3/10 - The boat is about the only creative thing on this server. They have cannons that shoot fire, and sometimes there is a storm while you are riding on it. The Q Menu is a new style, but it is not very good and could use a background or something.
Levels - 3/10 - The levels are nothing special, most of them are ugly but a few of them are fine. There aren't many levels on this server to judge.. I finally got to the main island, the levels are horrible.
NPC's - 4.5/10 - There were some really neat NPCs like the Clothes designer.. But everything else is cheaply scripted, including the NPCs on the main island. Very bad NPCs.
Quests - 2/10 - The quests I have found so far were just slash the baddies, and had no connection with what storyline there may have been. The quests are aweful.. Try putting a reason for doing them.
Storyline - 0/10 - The intro, where you run down a road does not explain the storyline.. I have no idea what that was about, but it sure didnt have a story to it.
Overall score 12.5/50
Cynical's status:
Fail.
I know most people will agree with me after searching through most of the server.