[alarid0]

I can see the merit in the argument that it's too soft... adding some shine to it would certainly help. Calling it rubber, though... it has no environmental context right now. If the knife were placed directly into any game that goes for a realistic look it wouldn't fit, but this is more cartoony. It took a while for me to realize it but this reminds me a little bit of Monkey Island 4. As long as the rest of its surroundings kept with the cartoony look it would look good.

Adding shininess to the knife in that situation would still help a lot though xD

Oh.
Ah.
Anyways.
I like it :o