I actually tried to make a side scroller a few months ago, and had a test tileset in the making. But i did'nt have the scripters to do it, the thing is, i had loads of cool ideas for a side scroller, but i did'nt think it would become a server people would make their home server.
Tha Caribean merged with 19th century cannons and muskets would be really good, if it has a good development team.
And also, ive been thinking about using my ultimate tileset which ive never shown anyone, and alot of other professional pixel artists have touched it up and added to it also, so it's pretty much the best
I could probably post snippets.