Emerald
 

I need your opinion on this emerald icon...Which do you think is better and how can I improve it?

You're shading it as one entire entity. you should shade each facet individually as its own and not treat the whole thing as one item. Right now it looks like you took a shape and shaded it, then pasted the lines over it.

Needs more chaos.

first, its not a flawd

It doesn't have to be real. There are these things called the "boundaries of fantasy" and this fits well within them.

Yarr...I'll try again tomorrow and see what I can do.

Also, none of y'all answered my question >_<

That's 'cause it's hard to choose when they all face the same problem :)

You could still try :[

i like it ;)

Number 2!

i like the far left and far right one. On the left one, add those white shines i showed you yesterday ^_^ And on the far right, make it so all the faces are clear so people can actknowledge the shape of it straight off.

Then add shines! :D <3

Second one is best.

A diamond:

Think I'm going to redo the emerald to make it bigger and probably a different shape.

It looks kind of dull.

I dont like that diamond at all :(