A tree..
 

Heres a tree if you want a tree made by me just ask..
http://i10.tinypic.com/2qscqgz.png

That's quite pretty.

thanks
 

thankie

I don't know why, but it reminds me of Ragnarok's Graphics. :( gj. O:

wow

Woah, that's really good. I wanna see more GFX by you.

It's pretty but my paranoia is really reacting right now. I've never heard of Ben doing graphics. :\

Yea, I would like to see some more graphics aswell.

Me too. z.z I want proof he made this.

Yea, I got that. Let's not discourage him.

It's not that I want to discourage him. But whether he realizes it or not I've known him for a WHILE and have never seen or heard of him doing graphics of this QUALITY. If all his graphics are like this might as well put him up there with Elk and Tom. :mad:

Lol this thread reminds me of when I first started posting my good work.

The difference is I suppose everyone had seen you post graphics BEFORE that were crappy? Or something?

Back when you always AIMed me saying "hay" and told me updates about sanstrata and asked me to work there. :cool:

Donald I remember your first graphic, the "helicoptor" made out of a couch, etc.

Why are there random black outlines?

i dont believe for a second you gfxed that purely by yourself.. thats probably the single most freakin ownage tree i have ever seen pixalized and i just dont believe you made it

Hmm.. looks very familiar.

ignore the geeks, i like it ^^

i dont believe it was pixelled, it looks more like green scrumbled paper triangularised, but i do lik ths shading. Define the leaves more possibly and get rid of the jaggedy edges?

wow nice tree =))))

Notice how he stopped responding.

From the looks of the random black outlines, jagged edges etc - Id say he was playing a game, took a printscreen and cropped out the tree.

If he didnt though, its a great graphic!

i would go by luda's tutorial
on his sig

Well, of course its cool. But I am very sure I have seen it before :\

Yeah it does look familiar

It is stolen
I can't prove it but it is...
My eyes don't lie

But looking at this post, proves that he doesnt have creativity
http://forums.graalonline.com/forums...9&postcount=27

every good GAT can build...and im serious, every.
Since ever then he couldnt have improved that much.

Have a nice day Mr Graphic Admin.

My exact speculation.

Ive seen a tree very similer in a video game

Hmmmm final fantasy tatics GBA ,
Or was it a defrent game .....its very fimiler

whatever believe what you want that level was amde awhile ago i didn't stop responding i had to goto bed

how excactly could i have stolen it from a game threw a screen shot considering there would have been more detail, i use textures..

I'm usually a stickler for people finding proof on this, but it's also hard for me to say that when I notice that there are discolorations on many of the edges, not to mention, some that have what I often refer to as an unusual sort of 'pixel overhang' where the proper edges should be.

Coincidentally, it's also very odd to see that every one of those odd shades is a shade of cray, in the hue map of red instead of green.

Time for Zideruic's disection of this!

http://i12.photobucket.com/albums/a2...eruic/uhoh.png

Just observations buuuuttt...

Haha, I actually did that before you. :p

The dicolors and / or misshapenness usually are combined, though.

damnit the picture you made didnt load for me XD

Yeah I didn't see the pic untill my second visit to this thread.
Anyways If you made the tree Ben I like it alot, if not bleh.

just have him make something else, and if it looks like (ragnarok?) then he stole it, if it doesnt, then he made it...

of course it would have to be of the same quality D:

that's not from RO

http://i10.tinypic.com/2eusa4o.png

SEE

....Ok now your just taking the monkey wrench. That's stolen, as soon as i remeber the name of the game i will say. I played it about a month ago.

I dont like to say people stole stuff, but i dont like it when they just continue to lie and steal other artists work. In the real game there arent any crappy black outlines like that.