You guys need something to do
 

Rate 1-10, a-j, etc.

j7qx9 / z8vb7.

The base grass needs some more detailing.

The desert tiles also look a bit out of place with the sand and grass so close.

Nice layout, bad detail. 6/10.

needs more detail
;D

layout = really nice

layout:
1892368971264781698246 / 10

Detail:
6/10

h/10

6/10

Grass needs more detail.

8/10
it would have been a 9/10 if there were more detail in the grass...
(i never give out a 10/10)
I really like your use of the cliff tiles... that must have taken you a while to get so good at useing them
=)
also, the grass, and water, and shadowing, show that you are experienced with the tileset. From what I can tell, you can probably do better. ;)

nice.

5-6/10

Nice but you need more grass detail

6/10

very bland:(

More Detail For Sure ;)

i wonder who the first person was to say "Needs more detail"
anyways i'm one of those who considers if you could actually walk around in a level rather then if it's jacked up with ground tiles

you can walk over 90% of the grass detail tiles

nice :) but not so much details 8/10

I think this level is very good. 8/10? Dunno, I think I just like cliff tiles.

It sure does not need more 'grass detail'.

I spot some tiling errors with the cliffs, most of which could easily be fixed, and I see that you did not care much about making the sand/grass borders fit where it touches the cliffs. It looks as if there was not put that much effort in, but I really like the layout and the cliff work.

8-10, detail with more grass or sand

Nice! But where are the npc people? You need that running space. You can reverse the mountain top tiles to make them look better.

Um... 8/10?

..also try fixing some errors in your cliffs and by the waterfall :)

its late, laaaaaaate. late late late.

i give it an 6h/10j or someting, make a little mroe grass detail and id ***** it