Whatsitnow?
 

Rate it on your own scales =P

7/10
I like it quite a bit :O But that little pond could not supply a waterfull. Make a stream or something going to the pond ;)

it looks ok :)
theres a few tile errors but its hard to make it fit good always
i dont really like that thing in the water or the half grass ;)

I love that style. 9/10

Wonderfully done, but yes, the pond couldn't supply that amount of water.

9/10, looks great

But I agree with the other two, the pond cant have a waterfall.. maybe make it into a hot spring or something? Add some steam maybe to make it more convincing :D

It's a nice and original layout, but it could use some more detail, and I agree that the waterfall couldn't sustain that pond. 7/10

Try puting a waterfall fown thw big part of the mouain into the pond.. then it'll look better;)

That's what I thought.

I got alot of comments on the falls, so I took em out.

You could have just removed the waterfalls, and placed corresponding tiles. Now it looks like an out-of-place watering hole.

I agree. It loses it's..."Edge". Well I don't know a word for it but it's just mot the same :(

I agree with those two. Leave the cliff edges around it.

i loved the first one... i actually give it 9.5/10 a few tile errors i spotted but overall a beautiful layout
edit : i did a quick scan and counted 30 tile errors but i still think its a 9.5

7/10

The detail is a little scarce, but other than that it's pretty good.

Nice level! but, keep the cliff edges at the pond, i doesn't look like a pond anymore :( re-add the waterfall, and make a waterfall coming down from the cliffs to the pond :)

The problem with leaving the cliffs is this. I made it drop down a level into the ground, yet it still has waterfalls going over a edge higher then it. I'd have to re-do that base and raise the pond up a level for the waterfalls to remain.
But quite personally I think a huge freaking mini-mountain sitting in the middle of nowhere would look like crap. Also I don't exactly like the little-water area in the middle myself, shallow water p1sses me off to no end.