First Look:Mylain Tileset
 

Hey its thrashsoul,the owner of mylain.
I am working on the tileset and here's a little preview!

Re: First Look:Mylain Tileset
 

Spanky:

*turns on nice mode*
Thats sucks
*turns off nice mode*

Re: Re: First Look:Mylain Tileset
 

Hey, if you're gonna knock someones work, why don't you tell them why it's bad and how they could fix it instead of being an ass and going "that sucks" and that's it.

yea ankt whatever your name is
how about you put some of ure work up

I like the tree's ok Just the normal trees with some lines over it though. The rocks I dont like there isnt any detail to them. Just solid color. Basically what Spanky is saying (or may its konidias posting) is The tiles have no detail to them primarily solid colors. The tree's are ok but unoriginal being as its just the normal tree with lines added. (which I personally like how it looks)

i like the trees lotz but not the rocks, too plain...x.x

What about the bushes?

Bushes arnt to shabby either :)

Good caz i did all that in 10 minutes...
I wanted you to reply to see what you liked and disliked
so know i know what to change...

Not bad but be more creative

I think he specializes in levels (or do you do gfx spanky?) anyway thrashoul I see pasrt of the old bush in your buse and dont just to lines I mean detail it more. As for the trees make a new trunk and work on the leaves once again just dont do lines. The Rocks, you need to redo them all. The bricks are alright maybe just a little touchup on them.

Ok that just sucks. I'm sorry, but there is no other word to describe it. All you did was put filters on the currently existing tileset, it would have taken 10 minutes to make something like that. I can't point out any 1 thing which is bad because its all bad. Redo everything, it all sucks.

soul get on aim

Based on whats in the screenshot....


+ The trees are nice. Similar to the originals but theres nothing wrong with that. 7/10

/ The bushes are ok 5/10
/ The path tiles are ok 6/10

- The rocks aren't detailed enough. 3/10

Overall - 5/10

Average. Needs a bit of work. Maybe change the bottom of the trees and add some detail to the rocks.

those arent that great man


and even before you start talking bad to me, then search the pw forum for Cira Baen

:)