New NEW NeW nEw Tilesets for Doragon Koden!
 

Yesterday while transporting containers to our new home, my brother was rumaging through one of them and came across an old drawing I had done when I was younger. This drawing was of an mountainous island with various structures and what not. But that's not where my new tileset idea came from...rather it came from the shape of the land and mountains...which was basically a rip from Super Mario World. Now, before you get the wrong impression, I did not, REPEAT, did not rip anything from SMW (well, maybe took a screen shot to get a couple colors :D). But anyway, here is the new default_tiles.png. It's sorta unfinished because I'm trying to decide if I should add like little grass sprigs to the 16x16 grass tile...otherwise, it's plain :(

Let me know what you think :)

It's pretty good. Mix of the old and the new. I would only find one problem with the trees. It seems to be too plain around the trees, and the julel (cliff edges) need to be a bit more detailed. But definately, your on the right track, good work :)

Heh yeah, GYoshi those trees don't match anymore. Heh I would suggest, though, you keep your old tileset so my trees don't get replaced :D.

Yeah...I suppose you're right...but I like the shape of the trees...so I guess I can reduce colors in it...give it a more cartoony-Earthbound-like feel :)

in regards to the tiki statue thing in the south-west corner of the tile set, that you changed to blue.

You missed the 2 tiles that were made for those dudes so they can overlap each other diaganol to one another. They are the 2 that i outlines with red in the gif i attached.

You should add a little bit of texture to the grass, it's a bit too pure green at the moment.

heh, I already knew that...I plan to replace that statue anyway...but until I can find anything worth replacing it with...it stays :)

yes...too much green is annoying...so I added some small blades of grass :)

ahhh
 

I don't care for those tiles. I can see that you (or someone) worked really hard on them, and that's great. I'm not saying your tiles suck, I just like the original set a lot better.

Here's what I think is wrong:
Grass : I dont like the color green, a little too bright for my tastes
Cliffs : Original Idea, Just the yellow/orange clashes with that color of green grass
Trees : Look great, just dont seem to fit in
Overall : New/Old things dont seem to fit in the same game (Like grave Next to the large puddle stone (Not saying you'd do that)

Here's what I like:
Outsides Of Houses: These recoloring jobs look pretty good ;)
Floor Patterns : Most of them look awsome
Steps And Pillars : These used to be gold, but now are cyan. I like them.


You asked for our opinion, here is mine ;)

You should also add them to do the borders of the diagonal cliff tiles etc., apart from that I like it.

mmmmkay: I dislike the colour of the cliff tiles.

I actually think it's nifty, reminds me of old NES games. :-P

mmmmkay: Accept they didn't use a filter ;D

I think it looks pretty good, maybe you should remake the house as well?

Can't say that I like it much... I prefer the old one.. Maybe it's just because I don't like bright colors in a tileset. :/