Should rocks have an owner tag when they are bombed out of the wall?
 

Well, should they?

I think it would be dumb cuz you dont own the rock it came out of the wall

But you should own an apple tree that comes out of the ground?

But we can own the apples we grow? Both require alot of money to do so why is it dumb?

ahh you posted that seconds before me :)

No, because someone bombs a bunch of rocks and leaves, comes back in a couple hours or couple days and your screwed over. Plus, lots of people give their rocks up, and it would totally slow down the whole mining process with owner tags

but you get like 10 rocks per thing...

well I dont care I dont mine, I dont farm, I dont do anything like that to get my money

Lol, well, you could say the same about trees, the rocks, of course, would have to become unowned if nobody hit them.

yea that is a good reason...

and also like the only way having owner tags would work is if they like disolved after like 1 hour or something...

but if that happens then the owner might get mad if there axe breaks and then they have to go all the way back and the rocks are gone

Well, rock stealing gets more people mad.

No, I know I would get pissed if I wanted to mine durbies and someone just beat me to the rocks, and I had to wait an hour before I could mine them again

Here's an idea, when someone leaves the dirt area surrounding the rocks, they all become unowned.

The dirt area would have to turn into no pk and you can't hurt people in it. because otherwise you could just attack someone out of the dirt area. And it should just be an ownership where after a few minutes of no one hitting any rocks, they are free.
Peoples axe break, no one complains about it. People only complain about theifs, people just live with the axe breaking.

Oh yeah, I forgot about that, but yeah, it would have to be no PK, and no bamboo too.