In France, there is a law that covers password stealing (it's about accessing a service with someone's else identity I think..)
Anyway, it's more than obvious, stealing people's password is forbidden...

What wrecked fool would do that?

I click and click Loriel and click Loriel again and again but I get no free gralats!!~
Omagawd, I'm going to sue your pants off for false advertising. >:O

Well, the internet isn't France, and Moon Goddess isn't a policewoman anyway. Her job is to enforce the forum rules.

All I am arguing is that Loriel didn't actually break a rule, because there was no rule for him to break.

Name one other use for it. Yes, feel free to run circles around me and say "TO POINT OUT THE EXPLOIT." I'll just say again "He could have contacted somebody." and you'd say "He tried and they ignored him", and then I'd say "He didn't try hard enough - and he should have used Forum PMs or posted a topic about it." :whatever:
You act like this is the only thing he's done.
For not trying hard enough to contact him, and instead using the exploit to, as far as we know, your advantage?
It's called common sense. I don't think it's listed because it's so painstakingly obvious.
You <3
Well gee, I guess since my bank doesn't have anything in the rules that say I can't hack their servers to get millions of dollars, then I can do so without any legal trouble. :cool: you're a *****

I act like this is the thing Moon Goddess wants to ban him over. Which it is.

It's not a rule. Therefore: The various claims that Loriel broke a rule are unfounded. I await an alternate reason to ban him.

Actually, there's a law against that.

The problem here is that you're very stupid. You lack any useful intellect, but without regard for this fact you are attempting to interpret my posts in a rational way. Inevitably, you fail. However, at times I can be wildly optimistic, so I'm going to explain my stance in greater detail, in the vain hope that you might actually understand it.

Loriel did something that, according to many people, is bad. Many say that he should be banned. Some of them are making the mistake of thinking that he broke the rules, and, as an upstanding member of the community, I took it upon myself to correct them. Loriel did not break any rules.

Read that last sentence again. Here it is: Loriel did not break any rules. Note that it is not quite the same as this sentence: Loriel did not do anything wrong. The first one is the one that I said. The second one is something you invented in your little tiny head. Indeed, I think that Loriel should not have done what he did, but that changes nothing. Loriel did not break any rules.

There are other possible reasons to punish him, of course (for example, your belief that he should be banned because you don't like him), but none of them are actually justified. Nobody, so far, has been able to show how removing him from the community will have any positive effect. Until they do, the cries for bans should be ignored, and those doing the crying should be treated with the disdain they deserve. That's you, by the way.

That's funny; we ban normal players for stealing accounts and have their websites taken down for having websites that claim to be Graalonline (I'm sure I would also be banned if I did something like this). Were Loriel not a scripter, I am certain he would be globally banned, not just forum banned.

I think that it would be a justified ban. It violates the rule of common sense, something someone in a global staff position should have. If I went on a playerworld and saw someone advertising a link for a site like that, my first action would be to take a screenshot and have Spark globally ban him/her. Don't pretend that you all wouldn't do the same thing; you're just circling the wagons.

You're asking yourself the silly question "does this violate a rule"? Does "arbitrarily" banning a person violate any rule?* No, it doesn't. The rules clearly state a Graalonline Admin reserves the right to revoke access based on their judgement. In my judgement, apparently Moonie's as well, and that of several other users, this act is inappropriate.

*I'm not conceding that this ban would be arbitrary, either.

What else?

What advantage? I sacrificed (expecting to be banned) my account to get fixed what you call an exploit. That is not exactly a horribly unfair advantage.

So I can make up reasons to get someone banned, announce it as common sense, and have Moonie banned for, dunno, living in Florida? There are a lot of evil people in Florida!

I have not used any services under someone else's name/account/whatsoever. I think falsely accusing people of crimes is not legal.

You are again mixing up banhammer-illegal and prison-illegal.
The bank is not going to omg ban you, but instead they are going to have you jailed.
If any of those whose accounts I stole (a.k.a. no one) wishes to sue me, go ahead.

Oh, that proves your points. Nevermind my post.

That is your interpretation, which is clearly irrelevant.

Kai, if I wanted to ban Loriel, I would have already.....I dont wish to ban anyone.
I knew why Loriel had done what he did, but that does not justify him doing something that would get anyone else banned, I should have banned him, and I apologize to the rest of the community for not doing my job because of Loriel's positin, and knowing the reasons why he did what he did. If I had thought for a second, that Loriel was actually stealing password, I would have instantly banned, but I knew why he did it, so I did not....even though a regualr member, or anyone else would have been banned, anyone sending links like this in game would be banned.

Kai, the only attack you are giving me is that I said "he broke the rules", ok so there is no specific rule that he broke, I will refrase it...what he did was wrong and bannable, and you cannot say it wasnt bannable, because people are getting banned for those kinds of links all the time.

You people act as if you think you really know Loriel...none of us do unless any one of you know him in real life, any one of use could do something corrupt at any given time for all you know. Nemesis did.....

I dislike the message this thread is sending other members of this community, and I dont want to go into detail on this statement for obvious reasons, but with Kai and Loriel's awesome, "noone can touch me", intelligence, I am sure they can figure it out
You are correct

I absolutely fail to see your point.
I do not know you. Please remove your moderation powers because I am afraid that you will go corrupt and delete random threads. oh, wait, it is not corrupt if you do it.

That isnt the point I was making, and you know it

No, not really.

That shows how little sense you have.

That seems at odds with your earlier statements.

Attack? What are you talking about?

Everything is 'bannable'. Can you actually explain how banning him would have any positive effect, though?

Nemesis was always a corrupt idiot. Anybody with eyes could've seen it from the start. Do not compare him to Loriel.

Obviously you feel that some people can be trusted more than others or you would not advocate their having powers. Was Unixmad wrong to appoint you to supermod, without knowing you completely?