i'd have to say that (for me) it would go...

theme - graphics - levels - scripting

because if some server has a wierd theme, then i wouldn't play it 0.o' but if they had a good theme, and desent graphics, then i might play it... if a server has those, as well as good levels, then i'm sold...

scripting is just a little extra, but that's just how i see it. Of course, if i was an NAT, i bet i would think scripting is uber important too.. but i'm not, i do levels, and a little simple graphics work, so the quality of what i know is more important to me.

actually, i think that's true... you look for high quality of what you know.. like Kai, and Criminal know scripting, so they look for good scripting in a PW... whereas i am good at levels, and ok at graphics, so i look for that....

A LITTLE EXTRA? Lets see you have fun on a server with NO NPCS. *sigh* That was an utterly stupid view...

Scripting is vitally improtantonplayer worlds.
True the graphics and levels may first draw you in which is important too but it will be the NPCs which keep you there. Usually the better the scripters the better quality and more variety of NPCs your going to be able to create.

I personally agree with you Falados. But I could see if all he does is PK then all he would care about is his sword shield and hearts. Everything else would be just a nice little extra. As the other stuff you can just select and put in a treasure chest.

lets see you make a fun server with NO levels, or ANY graphics?
:rolleyes:

you can't have a server with NONE of one of those things, now THAT is just "utterly stupid" :rolleyes:

but i do think that you can have a fun server with just simple NPC's... as long as the story line works well :)

a server needs graphics + levels + ideas + scripting

all 4 are important, since you NEED at least some of all 4... but the importance of each one is really opinionated, and changes from person to person

You implied that scripts were unimportant, giving no idication that they were a vital part of a playerworld. "A Little Extra", like they could be tossed aside as garbage. You DO need all the elements, i made no implication that you did not. (Although, it is entirely possible to make a workable playerworld using only scripts and 1 blank level)

the PW would not be accepted... i mean, i "could" make a PW with just levels, and no scripts, but it doesn't mean it would be good, or that it would be accepted.

and anyways, that wasn't what i implied, it was what you infered

i explained what i ment in my last post.

yes, scripting is needed in any good PW, as well as quality levels, and graphics, and origional ideas... my point was, to me as a player, scripting is not all too important, and i think there can be a quality PW made with just basic scripting.

so in other words... for me:

ideas > levels > graphics > scripts

i was just stating my preference, if you don't agree, then that's cool, you're a different person, and you're intitled to that :)

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Upcoming Playerworlds
 

I agree, that is very important. But graphics truly are important as well. You cannot have stupid 2 color graphics, I believe graal is at the minimun of acceptance, and GK to be a little above (some things like trees are very realistic, while others are not). Personally, the first thing I did was plan out everything, and second I planned out the tileset and how I would do the graphics.

Rather then design, I think planning is a better term for it heh.

Well, you must have missed what I said secondly....and also, yes there are people that can't script anything. People who do not know the language...script learning can relate to graphics learning if you think about it...

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Upcoming Playerworlds
 

Graphics are great, but they don't affect gameplay much (and I think we can both agree that gameplay is the most important thing?) Without scripting, you're limited to all the normal conventions for Graal - hearts, NPCws etc, and you don't have any freedom to go beyond those. You would be extremely heavily restricted and unable to provide anything new or interesting. Graphics are great but scripts provide the expression for those graphics. Scripts define the world, graphics just decorate it.

Rather then design, I think planning is a better term for it heh.[/b][/quote]

Well, the traditional term is 'game design'. Hence the job 'game designer'. All I did was drop the implied 'game' :-p

But hey, no need to argue over semantics. We know what we both mean now so there's no problem.

I think you might have misinterpreted me (or I you). You said that you can make any graphic, given enough time, right? And then you said that the same applies to scripting. But it doesn't. Experience, education, intelligence - all these things put limits on the things that you can create. Nobody will ever have enough of them to make everything they could possibly think of.

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Upcoming Playerworlds
 

So very true.
I would also argue, personality plays a large role in the maximum size project one is capable of completing.

When he only asked about the NPC Admin i thought he was looking for work :p

Why are you people arguing over which is better?

Anyone aspect doesn't hold the weight of the greatness of a playerworld. A truely great playerworld should have an equal balance of each. What would an awesome script be without some awesome graphics to go with it? What would super terrific graphics be if you didn't have a script to make it work?

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Upcoming Playerworlds
 

Yes I agree, I was just arguing which was more important...but I think all are.


Agreed.


Yes that is what I said, so let us leave it at what you just said and be done with it, because I agree completely.

Re: Upcoming Playerworlds
 

Rising Empires

1)It's about making empires from your stupid towns =D. With a lot to do, RP-style like Val.
2)Me, Cyrin
3)Agret
4)Dunno about Agret, me, i worked for several playerworld projects that all gave up 0.o Fallen Lands and Sojourn.
5)I just finished melee system, but i don't have an idea how long it 'll take...