DW watch the language, and guys try and give criticism or a valid reason for the score you give. "1" Doesn't help him much.

It's okay.
The blades shading needs a little bit more work.
Try adding a few extra shades of grey into it see how that looks.

Jeeze, maybe we were in bit of a rush... I was running off to school when I posted mine...

Telling him it sucks etc isn't going to help him.
Feedback is supposed to be positive while pointing out weaknesses which should be improved on.
Keeps confidence up and gives them an idea of what to work on.
Much like a coach in any sport. :)

Wait until you get home to post, Einstien...

HEY NOW!!!! lol

Plus... I'm not really the one to teach people graphics... unless... well... they have the gift.... but... even then it's hard to explain that kind of stuff.... bleh...

You all can't give me a break can u?
 

Give me a break gez. help me out a bit

it looks like crap and HERES WHY!
you only used 2 diffrent colors on teh blade and only 1 on the handle? i mean you need to COLOR it Super good with lots of shades then it might look better :O?

Yeah... lack of shading would be something... and that it's a bit thick around the edges.. maybe tone down the handle and the hilt... the blade might be fine after those two things are lessened... but please... shade!!!!!!

But is it good for a first time GFX i mean i
 

But is it good for a first time GFX i mean i am working on alot......

Re: But is it good for a first time GFX i mean i
 

Yes you really have to work on shading, a very big part of graphic making.

Re: Re: But is it good for a first time GFX i mean i
 

It looks kicken dude! just gotta work on the shading other then that I like it, Expecially for your first time gj!!

I like it alot becuase its going to be a sword for a new game i am making mabey hopefuly if i get a good staff together and i improve my skills into Graphics and also C++ skills mabey if i get some people together it will be even greater then Graal itself

Don't get ahead of yourself. :rolleyes:

You couldn't possibly think of all the wonderful things i have thought of i have million's of ideas in my head i am at school drawing up head sheets and also body sheets right now i dont know about what i am going to make i might make a wonderful game called "WarZone" PKer's will love it all day everyday nothing but a halflife online sparing/pking killing all who come online.