Been busy lately, :(
But here is what I did in my spare time tonight, its a WIP remake of the swamp dungeon from earlier... Im really lost about the flooring... The stone floor, is rather griddy, I kept chaning the positions of the brighter stones in hopes of fixing, but all to no avail.. The blackness with a border is were I need to put a unique pattern like in the first tiles for this dungeon... But I am rather tired now... :asleep:

http://img254.imageshack.us/img254/9250/capturegdi.png

Hey youre pretty good

One thing that is really detracting to me is the random noise dithering.

Ya, would have said so too

The texture on the floor is a bit repetitive.

And also it doesn't seem like much of a floor texture.

I kinda like it, I think it gives a nice texture to the wall.

I don't think it does. It makes the wall look busy and more importantly, messy.

another thing that i've noticed is that you keep putting your light source to the left.
which isn't a problem, as long as you're consistent, but it keeps creating these weird visual effects where it look like the left sides of objects are longer or slightly higher than the right side.

Well at first it had way less noise, but then I noticed how it appeared as if the bricks stuck out way to much then they should, so I applied noise... maybe it was a bad idea... x_x

http://img291.imageshack.us/img291/4598/brickz.png

Can we see a pic with the first wall tileset?

Ok..

http://img209.imageshack.us/img209/4598/brickz.png

I think it looks much better without the noise, it looks sharper and since you used so much noise on it, instead of looking like degraded brick, it just looks like a degraded image.

The bricks with noise seems to have more of a gloomy dungeon feel. As if the walls were covered with something that blended them all together.

The bricks without noise seem much more defined. Almost a brand new look that would fit a royal castle or something.

Although in this scene I agree with Maximus, it fits better when it is more defined.

I was kind of thinking of having the noisy on the inside and the normal one with a palette change and different frame for outside... But if you guys believe the less noisy one is better, so be it.

Well now seeing it the other way, I rather like it without so much noise.

You don't have to scrap the second one though, you could define the noise a little more and turn it into moss